The 2026 All-Underrated Team: Unveiling the Unsung Heroes of Baseball
The MLB Network's Top 100 Players list is a hot topic, but let's shift the spotlight to those who deserve more recognition. Introducing the All-Underrated Team for 2026, a squad of players who defy the conventional rankings and capture our attention.
Catcher: Ryan Jeffers of the Twins is a standout. Catching is a grueling position, yet Jeffers shines with a league-average OPS+ over the past three seasons, joining an elite group. His offensive prowess is set to earn him more playing time this year, making him a player to watch.
First Base: Nolan Schanuel, the Angels' young talent, is a rising star. Despite a rapid promotion, he's held his own with an OPS+ better than the league average. His impressive discipline and contact skills make him a future star.
Second Base: Xavier Edwards, a Marlins' gem, showcases defensive brilliance. His 2025 season saw a dip in offense, but his disciplined approach suggests a potential resurgence. With elite defensive skills, he's a Gold Glove contender.
Shortstop: J.P. Crawford, a Mariners' veteran, is an offensive powerhouse. His Gold Glove in 2020 is a testament to his defensive prowess. With a 108 OPS+ since 2021, he's among the top shortstops, offering a unique blend of leadership and performance.
Third Base: Ernie Clement, a Blue Jays' standout, faces a challenge. His postseason heroics and Team USA selection are notable, but he's listed here due to a lack of better options. His versatility and speed make him a valuable asset, as evidenced by his impressive WAR.
Left Field: Taylor Ward, an Orioles' acquisition, raises eyebrows. Traded for a top prospect, Ward delivers right-handed power in a scarce outfield market. His OPS+ since 2022 is impressive, making him a valuable asset.
Center Field: Jacob Young, a Nationals' enigma, is a defensive marvel. His offensive struggles are evident, but his highlight-worthy catches, including a kick-save gem, make him a defensive standout. A Gold Glove could be in his future.
Right Field: Matt Wallner, a Twins' mystery, intrigues us. His 2025 season is perplexing, with a high extra-base hit rate but few total hits. His underlying metrics suggest potential, and his OPS+ is impressive. Consistency is key for Wallner.
Designated Hitter: Dominic Canzone, a Mariners' gem, is a lefty powerhouse. His 2025 performance in a limited role was solid, especially against righties. While his sample size is small, his impact is undeniable.
Starting Pitcher: Merrill Kelly, a Diamondbacks' veteran, is a comeback story. After a journey through multiple leagues, he returned to the States and excelled. His recent record and ERA+ are impressive, rivaling top free agents and blockbuster trades.
Relief Pitcher: Danny Coulombe, an unsigned veteran, is a hidden gem. Despite his age and late-season fatigue, his past three seasons showcase elite relief pitching. His strikeout and walk rates are exceptional, making him a valuable asset.
This All-Underrated Team highlights players who defy conventional rankings. But here's where it gets controversial: are these players truly underrated, or are they hidden gems waiting to be discovered? Share your thoughts in the comments, and let's spark a discussion on the fine line between underrated talent and untapped potential.
